Larry Bodine is the operator of the Law Marketing Portal.
As a veteran Palm VII user, I was highly curious when Research in Motion
("RIM") came out with a Palm-sized 957 wireless BlackBerry handheld,
with real-time e-mail, an address and phone book, appointment calendar
and memo pad. Now after using the BlackBerry for more than a month,
I must say that I like it as well, and in some respects better, than the Palm VIIx.
Gone is Palm's big advantage of recording appointments, addresses,
phone numbers and to-do lists in a handy little device. The 957
BlackBerry does everything that a Palm VII can do - offering a calendar,
address book, task list, memo page, calculator and alarm.
Editor's Note: Research in Motion's BlackBerry 957 cannot
run third-party software, unlike the Palm VIIx. Users are limited
to the pre-installed applications that are loaded on the device.
| For E-mail Power Users |
|
|
The BlackBerry 957 is for e-mail power users. If you've ever
been stuck out of the office and unable to check your e-mail, the
wireless 957 BlackBerry is for you. If you are a
professional
who needs to send an e-mail
while you're on the road or trapped in a meeting, the BlackBerry 957 is what you need.
The 957 BlackBerry looks almost like a Palm device and is a
definite improvement over the dinky 950 model, which looks like a pager.
The 957 BlackBerry is smaller and lighter than the Palm VII and has a
rechargeable battery. The viewing screens are a similar size but I felt the
BlackBerry was easier to read. Both have the black-type-on-green-background
display. The BlackBerry costs $100 more at the full retail price. But the
compelling difference is that the BlackBerry 957 is a radio device that is
always turned on and has software that will re-direct incoming e-mail
directly to the 957 handheld. You are never out of touch.
For clarification: RIM
is the manufacturer in Ontario, Canada,
BlackBerry
is the hardware, and 957 is the model number.
|
|
Quick Comparison
|
| Feature |
Palm VIIx |
RIM 957 BlackBerry |
| Navigation |
Tap a stylus on the screen and
press the up/down scroll button to operate.
The screen may scratch over time. |
Use your thumb on a track wheel
to scroll and click, plus an Escape key to back
out of screens. |
| Text Entry |
Use Graffiti system
to draw letters or tap on an on-screen QWERTY
keyboard to type. |
Use thumbs on a 33-button
QWERTY keyboard including Shift, Alt, and Delete
keys. |
| Price |
$399 plus $10-$40 per month for Palm.Net. |
$499 plus $40 per month for airtime. |
| Transmitting Files |
Beam your business card and files
using the infrared port, send email using internal modem. |
Send an email message, no
beaming function. |
| Web Access |
Access the Web by downloading
applets from AvantGo to browse text versions of
websites; loads somewhat slowly. |
Access the Web by downloading
GoAmerica and using microbrowser to view text versions
of websites; loads somewhat slowly. |
| Weight |
6.7 ounces |
5 ounces |
| Dimensions |
5.25" high by 3.25" wide by .75' thick |
4.6" high by 3.1" wide by .7" thick |
| Screen Size |
2 5/16" by 2 5/16" |
2 2/16" by 2 3/16" |
| RAM |
8 MB RAM |
8 MB RAM |
| Wireless Access |
Raise the antenna to send
and receive email. |
Wireless modem is built in
and automatic. |
| Searching |
Find function searches everything
on the device. |
Search function searches only
messages--not memos, calendar, or addresses. |
| Batteries |
Two AAA batteries; need to turn
off to conxerve battery power. |
Rechargeable lithium battery
is recharged in cradle; device is always on. |
| Carrying Case |
Purchase after-market holster
with belt clip, approximately $50. |
Comes with a holster and belt clip. |
|
| Respond Immediately |
|
|
It was truly exciting the first time the BlackBerry
vibrated and peeped when a new message arrived (I know, I'm
easily amused). The alert felt very urgent. I could check
the handheld to see whether the e-mail was important and
respond immediately if I needed to. Like the Palm handhelds,
the BlackBerry 975 also comes with a docking cradle, which
allowed me to synchronize my Outlook address book and calendar
on my desktop computer.
I love the 957 BlackBerry's ability to look up a phone
number or email address anywhere, anytime. With that information,
I can send an e-mail immediately from a taxi, from an airplane
seat or from my favorite coffee shop. In the morning I can
check my appointments in a day, week, month or handy "agenda"
view, which displays only dates when I have an appointment.
I like being organized and this handheld keeps me on time and
in touch.
If you can program a VCR, you'll have no trouble operating a
BlackBerry. It took me a few tries to get the hang of the
tiny keyboard buttons, which mimic a desktop keyboard. But I
mastered it quickly. This compared to the tedious process of
learning to operate the Palm VIIx; it took me weeks to learn to
navigate in the Palm and to learn the Graffiti writing function.
Luckily I have a technophile friend who coached me and encouraged
me not to give up.
|
| Redirecting Email |
|
|
The BlackBerry redirects email from an existing email
account. The device is always on and connected, so I receive
email in real time. The 957 can be installed in two ways: to
redirect email from office email (which would require the
help of my firm's IS network staff) or to redirect my personal
email account. I chose to forward my personal ISP email so that
I could stay up-to-the-minute.
This meant, however, that I needed to keep a desktop PC on and
running all the time for the redirection to work. Redirection
simply forwards a copy of the message to the handheld; it does
not delete it from the desktop (unless I set it to delete email
automatically when I place the 957 in its cradle). Installation
was a hassle and I needed help from RIM's tech support staff,
which thankfully was very knowledgeable.
The Palm VIIx required me to get a new email address, at
Palm.net. Like many businessmen, I already have an office and
personal email address and I was unhappy about having to keep
track of yet a third email address. So I use the Palm VIIx
only to transmit email, although it can be used to receive as well.
Plus, to send and check messages I had to turn the device on,
raise the antenna, tap an icon and wait a minute for the mail
to arrive.
I put the BlackBerry into its cradle every day, so the
battery never ran down. The company says it'll run two weeks
without a recharge. To save battery life, I can set the 957 to
switch itself off - say at midnight - and to turn itself on at
6 a.m., and to make a beeping sound to wake me up in the morning.
The Alert feature can be set to sound a tone, vibrate, make both
a tone and vibrate, or show an on-screen message.
Like the Palm, the BlackBerry displays a reminder message on
the screen about pending appointments. Being a Palm veteran,
I kept tapping the screen but the message wouldn't go away.
Then I remembered that I had to press the Escape key on the
BlackBerry instead. Old habits die hard.
|
| Shortcomings |
|
|
A drawback to the BlackBerry is the miniature keys are hard
to see. On the BlackBerry, to type punctuation marks and numbers,
I must press the orange Alt key with the appropriate key. I
needed an up-to-date pair of reading glasses to see the tiny
orange period, apostrophe, and comma marks on the BlackBerry
keyboard. The punctuation marks are like specks of dust. The
keyboard does include a very handy Delete key, which is used to
get rid of typos, old messages and appointments in one click.
I decided to enter the information by using my desktop computer,
and then syncing the data over to the BlackBerry.
I was disappointed that the BlackBerry appointment calendar
doesn't show "all-day" events properly; it lists them all as
occurring at Noon. There is no way to create an appointment with
no specific time, as I can do with the Palm VIIx. I use my
calendar to record tasks and to-do items that I must do on a
particular day, without specifying a time; the BlackBerry's
inability to do this spoils this handy calendar feature.
|
| Browsing the Web |
|
|
One of my favorite things on the Palm VIIx is to browse the
Web, using its web clipping feature that shows text-only
selections of Web site. I can download news, weather, restaurant
listings, travel info, yellow pages, driving directions and
stock quotes. The BlackBerry does the same thing using the
GoAmerica's Go.Web or WolfeTech's PocketGenie service. GoAmerica
is preloaded onto the BlackBerry but costs an extra $10 to $20 per
month to use. When accessing the web over a wireless modem, both
the Palm and BlackBerry can make me wait up to a minute before I
see any content. The connection speed is about the same as a 28.8K
dialup modem. But it's tolerable if all I want is a quick weather
forecast or the after-the-close earnings report of a stock I'm
following.
Will the BlackBerry take the handheld market by storm?
It will be tough, because 88% of all the handheld PDAs run on the
Palm operating system (including Handspring Visor devices),
according TheStreet.Com. In addition, Microsoft is trying to
attract buyers of devices with its Windows CE operating system,
fancy color screens and the unnecessary ability to play music
files. Handhelds are starting to get junked up with pointless
features like a global-positioning unit, a clip-on camera and
voice recorder. In my opinion, this like putting antlers on a
cow - interesting but unneeded. If you primarily want email and
you want it immediately, the BlackBerry is the best choice.
|
|